Last week, I conducted a little experiment: I moved this newsletter from Tuesday to Friday.
The results? Clear as day.
Tuesday metrics:
Open rate: 64.71%
Click-through rate: 18.18%
Friday metrics:
Open rate: 47.06%
Click-through rate: 0%
Tuesdays won. By a lot.
Here's why I'm sharing this—it's not because I cracked some revolutionary code about newsletter timing. It's because this tiny experiment reminded me: testing doesn't have to be complicated, scary, or perfect to be valuable.
Why I Tested (And Why You Should Too)
When I first launched Marketing Minutiae, I sent it twice monthly on Fridays. When I accelerated to weekly sends, I switched to Tuesdays at the same time—two variables changed at once.
I wanted to isolate one factor. Did Tuesday actually perform better, or was it just the increased frequency?
Turns out? Tuesday is the winner for my audience.
But here's what matters more: I actually ran the test instead of just wondering about it.
How many strategic questions are you sitting on right now? Should you change your posting time? Test a different subject line style? Try a new format?
Most of us never find out because testing feels like this big, formal thing that requires weeks of data and statistical significance.
The Beauty of Small Experiments
Here's my approach: pick ONE element to change. Not three. Not your entire strategy. One.
For me, it was send day. For you, it might be:
Time of day you post
Subject line style (question vs. statement)
Newsletter length
Content format (story-led vs. framework-led)
CTA placement
Change that one thing. Watch what happens. Trust your gut when the data tells you something clear.
If I was testing for a client, would I run this for multiple weeks? Absolutely. But for my own newsletter with a small, engaged list? These numbers told my gut exactly what I needed to know.
What "Failure" Actually Looks Like
Let's talk about that Friday newsletter.
Yes, the numbers were down. Yes, the click-through rate was literally zero. But you know what didn't happen?
Nobody unsubscribed. People still read it.
That's the thing about small experiments: the downside is minimal.
If Friday had performed better, I would've unlocked new potential in my content strategy. Since it didn't, I learned something valuable and moved on. No harm, no foul.
The worst-case scenario of testing is that you revert to what you were doing before, which means you're exactly where you started, just slightly wiser.
I've run other experiments that didn't yield results as clear as these. I tested different times of day for sending and got no clear throughline—no obvious winner emerged.
But even that taught me something: for my audience, time of day matters less than day of week.
Not every test will give you a definitive answer. Some experiments are messy. Some need more data. All of them are worth doing.
When you start experimenting, you stop guessing and start knowing. You build confidence in your decisions. You understand your audience better. You give yourself permission to try things without the pressure of getting it perfect.
Your Turn
Pick one element of your content strategy and test it this week.
Not a complete overhaul. Just one small variable.
Change your posting time. Try a different subject line style. Shorten your content. Add a question to your CTA. Whatever you've been wondering about.
Run it for a week (or two, if you want more data). Look at the numbers. Trust your gut.
If it works, you've just improved your strategy. If it doesn't, you've learned something and you can go back to what you were doing before.
Either way, you're better off than you were when you were just wondering.
Thanks for being part of my experiment! Clearly, you all prefer Tuesdays—and honestly, so do I 😉
What have you experimented with in your own content lately? Or what have you been curious about testing but haven't yet? Hit reply and tell me. What can I say, I’m shamelessly nosy!
Until next Tuesday (obviously),
Amanda ✨
P.S. If you're sitting on a content strategy theory you've been meaning to test but need a sounding board to see if it’s worth it, book a strategy session here and let's talk through it.

